The Neshaminy
Board of School Directors met in public session on August 28, 2001 Tawanka
Elementary School. The following
persons were in attendance:
BOARD MEMBERS:
|
ADMINISTRATORS:
|
Mr. Edward
Stack, President
|
Dr. Gary
Bowman
|
Mr. Steven
Schoenstadt, Vice President
|
Dr. Raymond
Boccuti
|
Mrs. Yvonne
Butville
Mr. Harry Dengler, Jr. |
Mr. Harry
Jones
Mr. Richard Marotto |
Ms. Carol
Drioli
|
Mr. Joseph
Paradise
|
Mr. Richard
Eccles
|
Mr. P.
Howard Wilson
|
Dr. Ruth
Frank
George Mecleary, Jr., Esq. |
Mr. Bruce
Wyatt |
|
SOLICITOR:
|
BOARD MEMBER NOT PRESENT:
Mrs. June Bostwick |
Robert R.
Fleck, Esq.
OTHERS:
Approximately 80 persons from the |
SCHOOL BOARD CANDIDATES:
|
public,
staff and press
|
Ms. Irene
Boyle
Mrs. Kimberly Jowett |
|
Mr. William
Spitz
|
|
|
|
SECRETARY:
Mrs. Carol Calvello
|
|
Call to Order - Mr.
Stack called the Work Session portion of the Public Meeting to order at 9:20
p.m.
Motion: Agenda
I move
the August 28, 2001 Work Session and Public Meeting agendas be combined.
I further move a motion regarding the Assistant Superintendents contracts
be added to the Public Meeting portion of the agenda following the
student/advisor attendance at PASA/PSBA conference motion.
Dr. Frank
seconded the motion. The Board
approved the motion with eight ayes.
Announcements - Mr.
Stack announced prior to the Public Board Meeting, an Executive Session was held
to discuss personnel items and contract issues.
Mr. Dengler
announced he will abstain from voting on the personnel actions because his
daughter�s name is included on
the report and the Extra-curricular Staffing and Salaries Report (see attachment
I).
Items for Discussion
�
District
Handbook - Handbook distributed at the meeting.
Dr. Bowman advised the Board all District employees receive a copy of the
handbook, which lists the policies, practices and procedures of the School
District. The administration hopes
to eventually make the handbook available on the District�s Web Site.
�
High School Graduation
Project - Information distributed prior to the meeting.
Dr. Bowman explained every public high school student in the Commonwealth
of Pennsylvania must complete a graduation project to meet the requirements to
receive a high school diploma. Neshaminy�s
approach to the high school graduation project is that it is educationally sound
and good for students. It is a
challenging project. In order to
provide training to the staff, the first three days of high school will be half
days. By the end of the week, every
high school tenth and eleventh grader will be matched to a mentor.
Every teacher will be mentoring a group of students at Neshaminy High
School. A pilot program was
conducted in 2000-2001 and the District is ready to fully implement the program
this year. Implementation is
scheduled to begin in September.
Mr.
Mecleary stated the Educational Development Committee discussed the high school
graduation project at its recent meeting. He
explained when the faculty vote was taken on the project, it passed by a vote of
113 to 13. Neshaminy�s project
program is the Cadillac of graduation projects.
It is a project to learn from and something to accomplish.
It is the committee�s recommendation that the Board support the
proposed high school graduation project program.
�
Communities that Care
Program - Information distributed prior to the meeting.
Dr. Bowman informed the Board the Communities that Care Program involves
all communities in Bucks County. It
is a nationwide program. A large
grant of funds has been made to the County Commissioners.
Lower Southampton Township, Middletown Township and the four Boroughs
located within Neshaminy are involved in the program.
The program facilitator is Nat Cooper, a resident of Langhorne.
The Neshaminy community has received a $40,000 grant for implementation.
Some of the program activities include planned after school activities.
Currently, a review is being conducted to determine availability of
District facilities for after school activities.
�
Revised 2001 Board
Meeting Calendar - Information distributed prior to the meeting.
Dr. Bowman informed the Board in order to coordinate its fund raising
event for the wall of plaques, the Neshaminy Education Foundation has requested
the October 23 Board Meeting be held at Neshaminy High School.
There were no objections to the meeting location change. Advertisements of the meeting will list the new meeting
location.
Items
for Approval
·
Overnight
Trips - Information distributed prior to the meeting ia
self-explanatory. Dr. Bowman
presented the following trips for approval:
·
Wrestling
Team - Philipsburg Tournament - Neshaminy High School, Philipsburg, PA, December
8-9, 2001
·
Wrestling
Team - Manheim Tournament - Neshaminy High School, Manheim High School,
Lancaster, PA, December 27-28, 2001
·
Foreign
Language Trip - Neshaminy High School, Quebec, April 17-21, 2002
There
was Board consensus for the three overnight trips.
·
Student Attendance at
PASA/PSBA Conference - October 16-19, 2001 - Dr. Bowman advised the
Board that a motion to authorize the attendance of two students and their
advisor at the PASA/PSBA Conference, October 16-19, 2001, will be presented at
the Public Meeting portion of the August 28 Board Meeting.
It is a valuable experience for students and participation in the
conference benefits the local student government program.
·
Approval of Bids -
Mr. Paradise reviewed the following bids:
Bid
No. 02-15 - Musical Instruments
Award
Amount: $24,568.05
The
bid is for musical instruments and accessories for grades K-12 instruction
throughout the District.
Bid
No. 02-16 - Stationery Supplies
Award
Amount: $40,000.00 (estimated)
The
bid is for miscellaneous office supplies purchased throughout the school year as
needs arise. The discount is based
on the United Stationers catalog which is used by many retailers in our portion
of the country.
The
bids will be presented for approval at the Public Meeting portion of the August
28 Board Meeting.
Items
for Information
·
Summer
School 2001 - Information distributed prior to the meeting.
Dr. Bowman reported 229 students attended Neshaminy’s Summer School.
Of the 229 students, 189 were Neshaminy students and 40 were students
from other school districts. It was
a well attended program. The Summer
Stock Program was extremely successful. The
Summer School has been a self-supporting program.
A cost analysis of the program will be presented to the Board in October.
Due to the high energy costs, there is a concern about the need to
increase tuition if the program is going to continue to be self-supporting.
·
PSBA Award of Honorable
Mention for Annual Report to the Community - Information distributed
prior to the meeting. Dr. Bowman
announced the District received honorable mention under the special publications
category from the Pennsylvania School Boards Association for the Neshaminy 2000
Annual Report.
·
ASBO Certificate for
Excellence in Financial Reporting Award - Information distributed prior
to the meeting. Dr. Bowman advised
the Board that the Association of School Business Officials (ASBO) International
has awarded a Certificate of Excellence in Financial Reporting Award to the
Neshaminy School District for excellence in the preparation and issuance of the
fiscal year end 2000 comprehensive financial report.
Since its inception in 1972, the program has gained the distinction of
being a prestigious national award. It
is recognized by accounting professionals, underwriters, securities analysts,
bond rating agencies, state and federal agencies and education, teacher and
citizen groups. This accomplishment
is reflected in the District’s high bond rating.
The District obtains favorable results when it goes out to obtain funding
for bonds. Dr. Bowman congratulated
Mr. Paradise and his staff.
Committee
Reports
·
Educational
Development Committee - Mr. Mecleary advised the Board the committee is
developing its agenda for the next few months.
Anyone who has an issue they would like the committee to review should
advise Mr. Mecleary or Dr. Boccuti.
·
Educational Foundation
- Mr. Stack announced Mr. Dengler
will be replacing Mrs. Bostwick on the Educational Foundation.
Mr.
Stack requested the committees begin to schedule their meetings and advise him
of the committee meeting dates.
Future
Topics - There were no
future topics discussed.
Agenda
Development for the August 28, 2001 Public Meeting -
The agenda for the Public Meeting was previously distributed.
Correspondence
- There was no correspondence.
Other
Board Business - There was
no other board business discussed.
Adjournment
- Mr. Stack adjourned the Public Work Session portion
of the meeting at 9:35 p.m.
Call
to Order - Mr. Stack called
to order the Public Meeting portion of the meeting at 9:35 p.m.
Flag
Salute - Mr. Stack requested
those in attendance join in the salute to the flag.
Public
Comment - There was a two
minute time limit per speaker. Mrs.
Reboh, Langhorne, pointed out the alternative school will include students from
other school districts. She
questioned why $50,000 is budgeted for a drug and alcohol abuse counselor
for the alternative school. How
many of the alternative school students have drug problems, have been truant or
have been violent? She felt
the residents deserve to know this type of information about the alternative
school students who will be attending the school located in their community.
Mrs.
Pulcinella, Langhorne, asked the Board members how much it will cost to turn the
Tawanka School into an alternative school.
Why is it necessary to have a drug and alcohol abuse counselor on staff
at the alternative school? She said
when she voted for her Board representatives she felt they would keep education
and not the almighty dollar as the top priority.
She stated she was very disappointed that the Board members she voted for
have voted to close a school. Hopefully,
for the next election all the residents will be better informed of the School
Board candidates’ position on the issues.
Mr.
Filoon said it was his understanding in order to solve the District’s
problems, the District needed to close two elementary schools or one middle
school. What has changed that the
closing of only one elementary school will solve the problem?
Is the closing of one elementary school a band-aid or will it solve the
District’s financial problem? If
the action is only a band-aid, why has the decision been made to close the
Tawanka School? Will the student
busing decisions be made by the School Board or will a private company be hired
to design a plan? He noted the
Board is only committing to closing the Tawanka School.
There has been no commitment as to which school the Tawanka students will
be transferred to once the school is closed. He questioned if the Board had all of the facts before making
the decision to close the Tawanka School. He
felt if the Board had all of the facts, it might have made a different decision.
Mrs.
Heuer, Langhorne, said if the Tawanka School is supposed to be the smallest
school, why is the projected 2002 enrollment for two other District elementary
schools lower than Tawanka’s projected enrollment.
The percentage of use is lower in five other schools than the Tawanka
School. She questioned why the
Board decided the Tawanka School is the school to be closed.
Mrs.
Lanhan, Feasterville, referred to the alternative school proposal and questioned
if sufficient staff is projected for the alternative school.
She inquired about the cost of retrofitting the school to accommodate the
alternative school students. She
inquired if the special education students, who have no behavioral problems,
attending the alternative school will be integrated with the students who have
behavioral problems. She said she
would not want a special education student to be subjected to a student with
behavioral problems.
Mrs.
MacDonald, Langhorne, stated she knew of a child attending an alternative school
due to truancy. She said her
children care about their school, the Tawanka Elementary School. She questioned why the Board wants to take the Tawanka School
away from the students and parents who care for someone who does not care.
At the Tawanka School the staff knows all of the students and appreciates
family participation in the school. She
felt by closing the school, a message was being sent to the students that they
are not important.
Mrs.
Winther, Langhorne, inquired if the Board has made its final decision on the
closing of the Tawanka School. Mr.
Stack explained the final decision will be made at the end of November.
Mrs. Winther pointed out the
Tawanka School’s music room is a very small closet space.
The art teacher, Home and School Association and school store all share
one closet. Last year her son’s
fifth grade class was at full capacity. She
questioned how the determination was made that the Tawanka School is under
utilized.
Mrs.
Schmidt, Tawanka School parent, indicated she was opposed to the Tawanka School
being closed. She felt due to
disrupting and relocating the Tawanka students, in the future some of the
Tawanka students may become a part of the alternative school population. She said every room in the school is utilized.
Therefore, the school is being used to its full capacity.
Placing 52 students in an alternative school would result in under
utilizing the facility. She
questioned who authorized the overtime to cut the Tawanka School’s lawn on a
Sunday.
Mrs.
Dubiel, Feasterville, stated her children will be entering first and third grade
at the Ferderbar School and both of those grades are full to capacity minus two
children. How is the Board
proposing those classes will decrease when they are already at capacity?
Mr.
Lanhan, Feasterville, questioned the savings that will result from closing the
Tawanka School. He said the cost of
operating the facility as an alternative school will be greater than the savings
resulting from closing the school. He
questioned if the Board understands the requirements to deliver an alternative
school program. He inquired about
the costs for security, benefits and retrofitting the facility.
He felt the cost of operating an alternative school will be very close to
what it currently costs the District to educate the alternative education
students at out-of-district schools.
Mr.
Brut, Langhorne, inquired what type of students will be attending the
alternative school. He requested a
dollar for dollar analysis of the administrative restructuring be provided.
He inquired about the screening/search process for a Superintendent to
replace Dr. Bowman, who is retiring.
Superintendent’s
Report - Dr. Bowman reported
the following:
·
Personnel Report, which will be presented later in the meeting,
will provide the necessary staffing to open Neshaminy’s 14 schools.
·
The District will be accommodating over 10,000 students.
·
The first year of the new reading program will begin this school
year.
·
The teaching staff has been involved in workshops throughout the
summer.
·
The buildings are ready to accommodate the
students. Improvements have been
made to the facilities in accordance with the funds budgeted.
·
The transportation schedules are available
on the District’s Web Page.
·
The schools’ door will be ready to be opened to 10,000 students
on September 5.
·
The District has a tremendous teaching staff.
The service staff is committed to making the District a good place for
students.
Approval
of Minutes - Mr. Schoenstadt
moved the minutes of the June 5, June 12, June 26 and August 8, 2001 Public
Board Meetings be approved and Mr. Eccles seconded the motion.
The Board approved the minutes with eight ayes.
Treasurer’s
Report - Mr. Paradise
presented for approval the June 30 and July 31, 2001 Treasurer’s Reports,
subject to audit. Dr. Frank moved
the June 30 and July 31, 2001 Treasurer’s Reports be approved, subject to
audit. Mr. Dengler seconded the
motion. The Board approved the June
30 and July 31, 2001 Treasurer’s Reports, subject to audit, with eight
ayes.
Approval
of Bills and Investments -
Mr. Paradise presented the following for approval:
·
Bills for payment for June and July 2001
·
Six investments
Mrs.
Butville moved the June and July bills for payment and six investments be
approved and Mr. Dengler seconded the motion.
Mr.
Schoenstadt noted the bills for payment included some large PECO Energy bills
and fuel oil bills. He inquired how
the bills compare to the budget projections.
Mr. Paradise stated the new fiscal year includes additional monies, which
the District was required to budget for the increased energy costs.
The bills are within the allotments at this point, and the expenditures
are within the budgeted amounts. The
Board approved the June and July bills for payment and six investments with
eight ayes.
Bids
- Mr. Paradise presented the following bids for
approval:
Bid
No. 02-15 - Musical Instruments
Amount:
$24,568.05
The
bid is for musical instruments and accessories for grades K-12 instruction
throughout the District.
Bid
No. 02-16 - Stationery Supplies
Amount:
$40,000.00 (estimated)
The
bid is for miscellaneous office supplies purchased throughout the school year as
needs arise. The discount is based
on the United Stationers catalog which is used by many retailers in our portion
of the country.
Mr.
Mecleary moved the two bids be approved and Mr. Dengler seconded the motion.
The Board approved the motion with eight ayes.
Certified
and Support Personnel Actions -
Dr. Bowman presented the following for approval:
·
Elections - Certified Staff
·
Resignations and Leaves of Absence -
Certified Staff
·
Elections and Changes of Classification -
Support Staff
·
Resignations and Leaves of Absence - Support
Staff
·
Sabbatical Leaves of Absence - Certified
Staff (For Board Information Only)
Dr. Frank moved
the certified and support personnel actions be approved and Mr. Mecleary
seconded the motion. The personnel
information appears on pages H-1 through H-11.
Mrs. Butville
noted several individuals listed on the Personnel Report are Neshaminy graduates
who have graduated from college and came back to work where they received their
education.
Dr. Bowman
recommended the Board exclude item no. 18 on page H-3 of the Personnel Report,
because there is a certification issue that needs to be resolved.
Not approving item no. 18 will not have an impact on the start of the new
school year.
In response to
Mr. Stack’s question about new elementary level certified positions listed on
the Personnel Report, Dr. Bowman explained the collective bargaining
agreement establishes class size. When
class enrollment exceeds the maximum class size number, a new class must be
opened. Two new classes have been
authorized for the Tawanka School, one for the Lower Southampton School and one
for the Hoover School. The
additional positions are within the budget financial allocation. Over a three year period, the number of elementary teachers
has been declining. However,
sometimes it is necessary to split classes due to the class size issue.
Due to the class size issue, a .2 additional position has been authorized
at the Sandburg School. Since an additional 100 students enrolled in Neshaminy High
School over the summer, one additional position has been added to the high
school staff. Staffing costs are
within the budget appropriation for salaries.
Dr. Bowman
explained the District does have a sister schooling program.
After the beginning of the school year, if a situation arises that
warrants sister schooling the situation will be examined carefully. The last few years there has not been any sister schooling
done over the summer months. No
further adjustments are anticipated at this time.
There may be some additional changes after the opening of school.
Amendment to Certified
and Support Personnel Actions Motion
Mr. Stack
presented the following amendment:
I move
the certified and support personnel actions motion be amended to state item no.
18 listed on page H-3 be excluded from approval of the personnel actions.
Mr. Mecleary
seconded the amendment. The Board
approved the amendment with eight ayes.
Amended Motion: Certified
and Support Personnel Actions
Mr. Stack
presented the following amended motion:
I move
the certified and support personnel actions, excluding item no. 18 listed on
page H-3, be approved.
Ms. Drioli
seconded the amended motion. The
Board approved the amended motion with seven ayes and one abstention, Mr.
Dengler.
Extra-Curricular Staff and Salaries Report
- Dr. Bowman presented for approval the 2001-2002
Extra-Curricular Staff and Salaries Report dated August 28, 2001.
Mr. Eccles moved the Extra-Curricular Staff and Salaries Report dated
August 28, 2001 be approved and Mr. Mecleary seconded the motion.
Mr. Stack noted
the Board members received from the PSBA a
2000-2001 supplemental salary booklet.
A review of the booklet indicated Neshaminy’s supplemental salaries are
in the middle of the salary ranges.
The Board
approved the Extra-Curricular Staff and Salaries Report with seven ayes and one
abstention, Mr. Dengler.
Motion: Student/Advisor
Attendance at PASA/PSBA Conference
Mrs. Butville
presented the following motion:
WHEREAS,
the Pennsylvania School Boards Association and the Neshaminy Board of School
Directors encourage student delegates and their advisor to participate in the
workshops and activities of the annual PASA/PSBA Conference; and
WHEREAS,
in the past it was found that student participation in the conference benefited
the local student government program and helped students to understand the
purpose and activities of a Board of School Directors.
NOW,
THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that two students and their advisor are authorized to
attend the 2001 PASA/PSBA Conference to be held in Hershey, Pennsylvania from
October 16-19, 2001, and that related conference fees and costs be paid by the
District.
Dr. Frank
seconded the motion. The Board
approved the motion with eight ayes.
Motion: Assistant
Superintendents Contracts
Mr. Stack
presented the following motion:
WHEREAS,
the Board of School Directors appointed P. Howard Wilson and Dr. Raymond J. Boccuti
as Assistant Superintendents at the June 26, 2001 Board Meeting; and
WHEREAS,
the Board President and Vice President met with the Assistant Superintendents to
negotiate their respective contracts.
NOW,
THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Neshaminy Board of School Directors
authorizes the Board President and Secretary to execute the contracts (see
attachment II) for P. Howard Wilson and Dr. Raymond J. Boccuti
effective July 1, 2001 through June 30, 2006.
FURTHER
BE IT RESOLVED that the Board of School Directors authorizes the Superintendent,
Board President and Secretary to execute the applications for the commission of
P. Howard Wilson and Dr. Raymond J. Boccuti.
Mr. Eccles
seconded the motion.
Mr. Stack stated
he is very pleased with the selection of both Mr. Wilson and Dr. Boccuti to step
into lead positions in Neshaminy. With
Dr. Bowman on board, there is the opportunity for Dr. Bowman to assist them in
their efforts to be prepared to assist Neshaminy in the future.
Mr. Stack
referred to a question asked earlier in the meeting and stated Neshaminy has one
Superintendent. The District has
other individuals who are being groomed to assume additional responsibilities in
the District.
The Board
approved the Assistant Superintendents contracts motion with eight ayes.
Other Board Business-
There was no other board business discussed.
Correspondence -
There was no correspondence presented.
Board Comment -
In response to residents’ questions raised earlier in the meeting, Mrs.
Butville explained the public information packet distributed does not include
nearly all of the information that has been provided to the Board.
The cost of sending students to out-of-district alternative schools is
more than double the cost to educate the students in a District alternative
school. A large part of the
alternative school cost savings pertains to the savings in tuition payments.
Mr. Stack noted
the alternative school proposal includes for the first year using the
alternative school for Neshaminy students only.
If the program goes well, the District may open the program to students
from other areas in succeeding years. He
stated the District has only one Superintendent.
Other District administrators are being groomed for positions in the
District.
Mr. Stack noted a
public hearing was held at 7:00 p.m. at the Tawanka School to allow the Tawanka
area residents to present their comments. He
said there will be other sessions to discuss transition issues and/or changes.
The final decision as to whether a facility will be closed will be made
at the end of November. In advance of November, some steps will be taken so everyone
can understand the situation. All
the details will not be available, but an effort will be made to provide
available information.
Dr. Bowman
explained drug and alcohol abuse
counselors are currently used in the District through contracted services.
When dealing with a large population, 10,000 students, and many different
families, there are issues that must be addressed.
The same type of issues will have to be dealt with in an alternative
school. The first year of operation there will be regular education
placements in the alternative school. The
second year of operation there would be special education placements in the
alternative school. Seats can also
be made available to outside school districts after the first year of operation.
The cost of benefits are included in the alternative school costs listed
in the public information packet. He pointed out an alternative school is
currently located down the street from the Tawanka School.
He stated as more Board Meetings are held, more information will be
available to address the questions presented by the community members.
Some of the questions have been answered in previous Board Meetings,
because the Board has been discussing the issue for quite a long time.
Mr. Eccles moved
the meeting be adjourned and Mr. Dengler seconded the motion.
The Board approved the motion with eight ayes. Mr. Stack adjourned the meeting at 10:25 p.m.
Respectfully
submitted,
Carol A. Calvello
Board Secretary
|